Wow. Is there a better way to describe this film? Is it possible to have
a one-word review of a film? Wow. Maybe that’s all that’s needed. It’s hard to
know where to start when talking about this one. Do you talk about its sheer
massiveness? Do you talk about the acting? Do you talk about the brilliant
lighting and cinematography? What about the captivating musical score? Or maybe
it’s best to just start with Rainer Werner Fassbinder himself? The man was so
prolific during his short career that it’s nearly hard to take in everything (or even to find it all).
He made over 40 films in roughly a decade. And perhaps his greatest achievement
is this film, Berlin Alexanderplatz. In the annals of epic filmmaking, Berlin
Alexanderplatz makes most “epic” films seem very small indeed. Clocking in at
940 minutes, including 13 “episodes” and 1 epilogue, it is as big and epic as they
come. And that’s an understatement.
Originally aired as a mini-series on German TV, this film has finally
become more accessible with Criterion’s release several years ago, in a huge 7
disc set. I have watched it for the first time, after spending the last couple
years digging through Fassbinder’s canon of films. I’m actually glad I waited
to see this until now, because I feel like I was better able to appreciate
the scope and breadth of the film and understand how the themes and design of the work fits with Fassbinder's other works. Based on Alfred Doblin’s novel of the same
name, Fassbinder’s film details the troubled life of the hulking man-child Franz Biberkopf (an unforgettable Gunter Lamprecht),
from his murder of his girlfriend, to being released from prison, his delving
into alcoholism, and troubled relationships with various women, involvement
with a group of criminals where he ends up losing his right arm due to an
accident. In the film’s final episodes, he finds fleeting love with a beautiful
woman he calls Mieze (Barbara Sukowa), but she meets an untimely death, whereupon his despair
is unquenchable. In the absolutely outrageous 2-hour epilogue, we see his
experiences in a hell-like place, where he is subjected to horrific visions and
experiences as one of cinema’s most unrelenting, and unforgettable passages is
told.
I’m not so sure that the film could necessarily be considered enjoyable
per se. But it’s the sheer weight of the thing and the incredible command of
the screen and the material that Fassbinder puts on display that makes it so
good. I started out watching episodes rather infrequently, but as I worked my
way through, I found it to be more and more compelling and watched with more
rapid fervor. What
Fassbinder is able to do with such a long running time is create a literary arc. Rewards for watching this film come from the depth, slowly built throughout the story just as one would find in a great novel, and it really compares very well to literary storytelling, perhaps even more than cinema itself. If you asked me to pick a few favorite episodes, I would probably choose 7 and 11 as my personal favorites. Episode 7 is filled with some incredible lighting and suspense, and contains some of the best acting in the entire series. Episode 11 remains unforgettable due to the knock-down drag-out fight between Franz and Mieze. This extended moment of conflict and human violence is incredibly troubling, as he nearly kills his love out of jealousy and rage, but simultaneously "loves" her all the same throughout. It is a devastating scene and one of cinema’s most memorable clashes, as they brawl along the floor for what seems like an eternity. Mieze’s screaming pleas at the top of her lungs echo as an expression of life’s pain and misery. It is a moment of pure, agonizing release.
Fassbinder is able to do with such a long running time is create a literary arc. Rewards for watching this film come from the depth, slowly built throughout the story just as one would find in a great novel, and it really compares very well to literary storytelling, perhaps even more than cinema itself. If you asked me to pick a few favorite episodes, I would probably choose 7 and 11 as my personal favorites. Episode 7 is filled with some incredible lighting and suspense, and contains some of the best acting in the entire series. Episode 11 remains unforgettable due to the knock-down drag-out fight between Franz and Mieze. This extended moment of conflict and human violence is incredibly troubling, as he nearly kills his love out of jealousy and rage, but simultaneously "loves" her all the same throughout. It is a devastating scene and one of cinema’s most memorable clashes, as they brawl along the floor for what seems like an eternity. Mieze’s screaming pleas at the top of her lungs echo as an expression of life’s pain and misery. It is a moment of pure, agonizing release.
But that scene is also a microcosm of Fassbinder’s filmmaking. His
stuff is often difficult to watch. His approach is often very raw, awkward, and
nakedly emotional, leaving one feeling uncomfortable and troubled. At times the
film is all of these things: glorious, breathtaking, inspirational, but also
annoying, disturbing and exasperating. One cannot sit and watch this film
passively. This is a film that will slap you in the face and shake you up
repeatedly. And I realize it’s also probably not everyone’s cup of tea. There is no arguing with the high degree of
acting quality on display though, and this film contains a cavalcade of
Fassbinder regulars….everyone from Gottfried John, Elisabeth Trissenaar, Brigitte Mira, Volker Spengler, to the absolutely perfect
Barbara Sukowa as Mieze and Hanna Schygulla as Eva. Every performance in the
film is spot-on and there isn’t a weak link in the bunch for the entire 15
hours. Furthermore, the lighting and cinematography adds emotional and
psychological depth. I would also be remiss if I didn't mention the musical score, by Peer Rabin, which is haunting and enigmatic throughout.
After hearing so much about this film for several years, I was thinking it
would be hard to live up to expectations, but this film surpasses them. It is
without a doubt, one of the very best films ever made.
Yes Rabin's score is stunning too Jon. You have penned an extraordinary review on what of the cinema's supreme masterpieces by one of the most troubled of all cinematic renegades, one whose workaholic and substance abuse eventually caught up with after one of the most prolific careers in a life ended at a young age. BERLIN is arguably his masterpiece and you do a fabulous job connecting the dots. Lamprecht is indeed unforgettable (as is Sukowa) and the film's despair-driven coda is in collaboration with the director's own philosophical convictions. This is a real hell on earth, and the film leaves you shaken. I watched it a few years back in a two day span.
ReplyDeleteTerrific review Jon!
Hey Thanks Sam. I am impressed by the fact you watched it in two days! That is indeed a feat and I'm thinking would be a slightly different experience than mine was, which was stretched out a bit. I consider this film to be one of the most incredible things I've ever seen. It's a knockout.
ReplyDeleteJon, I have been obsessed with B.A. since watching it many years ago. In case you're interested I wrote a book loosely based on the story of a Franz type character but which takes place in "Weimar Russia" i.e. the early years of Yeltsin. Take a look if you're interested, thanks. Not trying to spam you just trying to get the word out. http://www.haymarketsquarebook.com/
ReplyDelete